Avoid legal and reputational risks by complying with fair hiring laws in California. Support second chances and help build a more inclusive workforce.
As an employer in California, it's crucial to stay informed about laws that impact your hiring practices. Recently, the California Civil Rights Department (CRD) announced settlements with major retailers, including Amazon, Ikea, and Kohl’s, for allegedly violating the Fair Chance Act (California Settles with Big Box Retailers, Amazon, and Others Over Alleged Violations of State Fair Chance Act | CRD). These developments serve as a reminder of the importance of compliance and the significant implications for your organization.
What is the Fair Chance Act?
The Fair Chance Act is designed to reduce barriers for individuals with past arrests or convictions, ensuring they have a fair opportunity to secure employment. It prohibits employers from inquiring about a job applicant’s criminal history before extending a job offer and limits the convictions that can be used to disqualify candidates. This law acknowledges that nearly one in three adults in California has an arrest or conviction that could hinder their job prospects.
The Risks of Non-Compliance
The recent settlements highlight the potential legal and financial consequences of failing to comply with the Fair Chance Act. Companies that have violated this law faced not only monetary penalties but also reputational damage and the need to implement corrective actions. Here are specifics about each company involved in the settlements:
- Amazon: Allegedly denied a Bay Area applicant the opportunity to work as a delivery driver due to a conviction that was over seven years old, failing to follow the required hiring processes.
- Ikea: Was found to have failed to demonstrate a direct relationship between an applicant’s conviction history and the duties of a job as a furniture builder in Carson.
- Kohl’s: Denied an applicant a position as a warehouse worker in Los Angeles based on criminal history information unlawfully obtained through a criminal history questionnaire.
- Los Angeles Dodgers: Failed to notify an applicant for a guest services job of the specific reason for blocking their hire and did not provide an opportunity for the applicant to challenge that reason.
- The Citizen Hotel: Unlawfully considered criminal history information that had been sealed, dismissed, or expunged for a person applying for a job as a bartender in Sacramento.
- MPIJet: Also unlawfully considered sealed, dismissed, or expunged criminal history information for an applicant seeking a job at a private charter jet company in Monterey.
These violations not only resulted in financial settlements but also necessitated significant changes in their hiring practices.

Benefits of Embracing Fair Hiring Practices
- Enhanced Reputation: Companies that adopt fair hiring practices demonstrate a commitment to inclusivity and social responsibility, enhancing their brand image.
- Wider Talent Pool: By considering candidates with past convictions, your organization can tap into a diverse talent pool that includes skilled individuals who may have faced barriers in the past.
- Increased Employee Loyalty: Employees appreciate working for organizations that value fairness and second chances, leading to higher job satisfaction and retention.
How to Ensure Compliance
To navigate the complexities of the Fair Chance Act effectively, employers should consider the following steps:
- Conduct Training: Educate your HR team on the requirements of the Fair Chance Act, ensuring they understand how to implement fair hiring practices.
- Revise Hiring Policies: Update your hiring policies to align with the Fair Chance Act, making it clear that criminal history will only be considered when it has a direct and adverse relationship to the job.
- Implement Individual Assessments: Establish a procedure for conducting individualized assessments of applicants' criminal histories before making any adverse employment decisions.
- Provide Clear Communication: Ensure that all applicants receive written notice if their criminal history is a disqualifying factor, along with an opportunity to present evidence of rehabilitation.
Seeking Expert Guidance
Navigating compliance with the Fair Chance Act can be challenging, and seeking expert guidance can help mitigate risks. As an HR consulting firm, Bhravo specializes in helping organizations like yours develop effective strategies for fair hiring practices while ensuring compliance with state laws.
If you’re ready to enhance your hiring practices and foster a more inclusive workforce, let’s connect! Together, we can build a strong foundation for compliance and create a positive impact in your community.
In conclusion, understanding the Fair Chance Act and its implications is crucial for employers in California. By embracing fair hiring practices, you not only comply with the law but also contribute to a more equitable workforce. Don't wait—take proactive steps to ensure your organization is on the right path!